Standards & regulation

An EU Court Adviser Wants Google’s AdSense Fine Reheard. Her Test Judges Publisher Contracts As A Set

Hamit Tümer ·4 min read·How we report Share Print
In this piece
    No one lock holds the gate; the row of them does.
    No one lock holds the gate; the row of them does.

    The story. An adviser to the EU’s top court says the General Court was wrong to cancel Google’s fine of almost €1.5 billion over AdSense for Search. Her opinion is not binding and changes nothing yet. The test she proposes matters more than the money: regulators may judge a dominant platform’s publisher contracts together, not one by one. (Court of Justice of the EU, press release 164/26, 12 November 2026)

    01What happened

    • The product. AdSense for Search (AFS) put Google search ads on publishers’ own site-search results, and the publisher received a share of the revenue.
    • The contracts. From March 2009, Google’s template Google Services Agreements for AFS restricted or banned ads from competing services, the court says.
    • Three clauses. An exclusivity clause, a placement clause and a prior-approval clause. Google dropped or amended them in September 2016.
    • The placement clause. Publishers had to show a minimum number of Google ads and could not put rival ads above or directly beside them.
    • The prior-approval clause. Publishers needed Google’s approval before changing how search ads were displayed.
    • The fine. In March 2019 the European Commission fined Google almost €1.5 billion for abuse of dominance between 2006 and 2016.
    • The annulment. On 18 September 2024 the General Court cancelled it, saying the Commission had not examined the length of the contracts closely enough.
    • The opinion. On 12 November 2026, Advocate General Juliane Kokott said that bar was too high and proposed sending the case back (C-826/24 P).
    • What she did not say. She did not ask for the fine to be restored in full. She said it should be reduced in any event, because findings about 2016 were not appealed.
    • Next step. The judges have begun deliberating. Judgment will come later, and the opinion does not bind them.

    Digiday set the opinion beside the US case. In September, Judge Leonie Brinkema rejected the forced sale of AdX and DFP and backed behavioural remedies instead. The terms of those remedies are still being worked out, and Google has said it will appeal on liability. We covered that timeline in October.

    02What it means for a publisher

    The conduct in this case ended ten years ago, and a fine paid to the EU budget does not reach a publisher’s account. The useful part is the legal test.

    Google won in 2024 by arguing that the Commission had not shown how long each agreement ran, or whether publishers could walk away. Kokott says the Commission does not have to take each contract apart. It may look at all the significant contracts on a market together, use averages where it needs to, and ask whether they could jointly push rivals out. If the Court of Justice agrees, a dominant platform cannot defend a network of publisher contracts by pointing to the short term or exit right in any single one.

    The three clauses also map onto terms a publisher still meets today. Exclusivity is now usually a condition of a revenue guarantee or a managed service rather than a line in a template. Placement rules show up as “first look”, minimum-unit or adjacency terms. Prior approval shows up as a partner’s sign-off on layout or wrapper changes. None of these is unlawful in itself. Our reading is that this opinion makes it easier for a regulator to examine them in aggregate when the counterparty is dominant.

    The commercial point is simpler. Every one of these clauses limits who else can bid on a page. A publisher that has signed them gave up competition for its own inventory. That has a price, whether or not a court ever looks at it.

    The adviser's opinion does not restore Google's AdSense fine, and the final ruling may still differ.

    03What publishers should do about it

    04The bottom line

    The adviser’s opinion does not restore Google’s AdSense fine, and the final ruling may still differ. What it does is argue for a test that judges a platform’s publisher contracts as a set. Whatever the court decides, terms that keep rival demand off your pages cost you money. Publishers should know which ones they have signed and what they got in return.

    If you want a second pair of eyes on how your demand partners are set up, see our publisher services. Related: Google’s Ad Tech Remedies Skip Deal IDs And PG. Publishers Are Taking The Win Anyway.

    Sources & caveats

    Sources: Court of Justice of the European Union, Press release No 164/26, Opinion of Advocate General Kokott in Case C-826/24 P, Commission v Google and Alphabet (Google AdSense) (12 November 2026), for the AFS service, the three clauses and their dates, the 2019 decision, the 2024 annulment, the opinion’s reasoning and the next steps. Digiday, “Ad Tech Briefing: Google’s antitrust troubles aren’t over” (17 November 2026), for the US remedies context. The reading for publishers and the recommendations are APH desk analysis, not legal advice.

    The weekly

    One letter a week, from the desk that runs the auctions.

    What actually moved in yield, CTV and curation across our publishers — written by the people who saw it, not a content team. No digests, no roundups, one email.

    One email a week. Unsubscribe in one click. We never share or sell the list.

    More from this issue

    Ran alongside this piece in the Weekly of 18 November 2026.